If you find value in this page, please use my referral links and keep me on the bed! It won't cost you a dime (in fact you'll usually get a discount), and I'll get a small commission, which is very much appreciated.

Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding Index:

  1. Introduction of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding
  2. Detailed comparison of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding
  3. Summary table of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding comparison with specs
  4. Final Verdict

1. Introduction: Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison, Before You Buy

One mattress offers general comfort while the other is a relative newcomer known for their taste and quality, meet Casper and Brooklyn Bedding. For this comparison, let’s check out how these two online mattress companies compare with each other.

If you’d like to read my full detailed mattress reviews, here’s Casper, and  this one is for the Brooklyn Bedding mattress.

2. Detailed Comparison Of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding:

CASPER

BROOKLYN BEDDING

U

Top Cover

Casper cover: two-tone shade with the top in white while the sides in grey. The top material is thin and porous which is great for breathability but also snags easily. The side fabrics can handle rough handling.
Brooklyn Bedding: Quilted comfort top with pillow-like design; two-tone design with logo running on the sides. Modern look and feel. It feels very sturdy.

Foam Layers

Casper 9,5-inches total, uses 4 layers: top layer is 1.5-inch poly foam creating a cool surface. Second layer is 1.5-inch memory foam with support and pressure relief. Third layer is the 1.5-inch support foam and the last bottom is 5-inch foam support and base layer. 
Brooklyn Bedding 10 inches total is made up of three layers: The top layer is 2 inch of Talalay latex designed for comfort and cooling. Second layer is 2 inch of Dunlap latex; third layer is 6 inch of poly foam for foundation base.

Firmness

The Casper firmness: The mattress provides neutral firmness – not too soft, not too firm.
Brooklyn Bedding: Available in three firmness options: soft, medium and firm. Pick one that suits your preference and need.

Body Support

Sinkage for the Casper isn’t as pronounced when weight is distributed evenly across the mattress. Lying down on the Casper gives you more hug as the foam almost instantly moves according to your pressure points, giving your body support.
Brooklyn Bedding body support: Excellent body support and offers good contour and hug without sinking feeling for the sleeper.

Motion Transfer

Casper motion transfer: Casper offers less bounce and very minor motion transfer.
Brooklyn Bedding motion transfer: Good bounce with minimal motion transfer.

Price

Casper prices:

twin size  : $550,
full size    : $800,
queen size: $950,
king/cal    : $1,150

$50 off with code GIRL50.

Brooklyn Bedding prices:

twin size  : $425, 
full size    : $625, 
queen size: $750,
king/cal    : $900.

Add $50 discount.

 

Trial Period

Casper trial period: Offers 100-day trial period like the Brooklyn Bedding. This risk free trial lets you return the product within 100 days in case you’re not happy.
Brooklyn Bedding trial period: 120 nights trial period offered, if you’re not happy with the mattress, you can return for full refund.

Warranty

Casper warranty: Same with BB, you get a 10-year warranty with the product.
Brooklyn Bedding warranty: Offers 10-year warranty period.

Shipping Period

Casper shipping: Free shipping is offered for those in the United States.
Brooklyn Bedding shipping: Free shipping within US except for Hawaii and Alaska; Shipping to those states cost $250

Returns

Casper returns: Casper picks it up and arranges for it to be donated to charity or forwarded to a recycling partner. Full refund within 100 days of the trial period.
Brooklyn Bedding returns: Offers 100% money back guarantee as long as mattress is returned within trial period

Casper Details:

Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding mattress comparison, casper vs Brooklyn bedding

Price: Starts at $550 (Twin) to $1150 (King)

Trial Period: 100 Nights

Shipping: Free shipping

Warranty: 10 Years

Made in: USA

Brooklyn Bedding Details

Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding mattress comparison, casper vs Brooklyn bedding

Price: Starts at $425 (Twin) to $900 (King)

Trial Period: 120 Nights

Shipping: Free shipping

Warranty: 10 Years

Made in: USA

3. Summary Table: Comparison of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding with Specs

CasperBrooklyn Bedding
Foam Layers:Total 9.5″ thick: 1.5-inch poly foam, 1.5-inch memory foam, 1.5-inch support foam,  5-inch high density support foamTotal 10″ thick: 2 inches of Talalay latex; 2 inches of Dunlap latex, 6 inches of support/foundation foam
Height:9.5 inches10 inches
Cover:Two tone white and gray cover; top cover is thin and breathable while sides are more durableTwo tone cover with modern appeal, quilted foam type layer
Firmness:Medium Firm (6.5 out of 10 in firmness scale)Available in Soft, Medium and Firm options
Support:GoodGood
Motion Transfer:Very minimalMinimal
Price:Starts at $550 for Twin to $1150 for KingStarts at $425 (Twin) to $900 (Split King/Split Cal King)
Warranty:10 years10 Years
Trial Period:100 Days120 Nights
Shipping:Free within US and CanadaFree except Hawaii and Alaska
Returns:Yes, 100% money backYes, 100% refund within trial period
Discounts:$50 off with the code GIRL50$50 – 100 off

The Final Verdict

Both the Casper and Brooklyn Bedding each feature plenty of advantages for various sleepers. The Casper is great if you want a mattress that’s essentially an “all around” mattress. It’s got good comfort, proper support and just enough bounce. Plus, the price is pretty good too. For the Brooklyn Bedding, it’s highly recommended for anyone who is after a great bounce, short of purchasing a spring mattress. There’s also equal balance between contour and hug that makes the mattress a pleasure to sleep on.