If you find value in this review, please use my referral links and keep me on the bed! It won't cost you a dime (in fact you'll usually get a discount coupon), and I'll get a small commission, which is very much appreciated.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Review: With more than 20 years of mattress experience under their belt, you can bet Brooklyn Bedding knows their stuff. Recently, they overhauled their mattress design and created what is touted as the #BestMattressEver.

Is it really the best? Or is this whole marketing thing simply hype to lure in folks with a penchant for cool hashtags? I’ve decided to get to the bottom of this to see if mankind has indeed found the best mattress ever created.

Come join me in the adventure.

Before anything, I think it’s important to mention Brooklyn Bedding is one of the most respected mattress companies in the U.S. And they have their own 145,000 sq. ft. factory! Basically, they have a say in the type of materials to include with their mattresses along with the various assembly specs they want. That part alone sets the company a whole league from other online mattress sellers.

With that said, let’s get down the foam layers.

Breaking Down the Layers:

Each Brooklyn Bedding mattress is a 10-inch thick mattress made up to three main layers:

Top Layer – 2-inch thick Talalay latex. Similar to Dunlap foam but a bit more consistent in bounce and performance, Talalay latex serves as the layer that’ll come in contact with your body the most. It provides comfort including a cooling effect.

Middle Layer – 2-inch thick Dunlap latex. It’s basically latex-on-latex sandwich with the Brooklyn Bedding mattress. Dunlap is durable stuff. It creates amazing comfort, bounce and a wonderful cooling effect so some companies use this as their top layer. The Dunlap, in this case, is underneath the Talalay because it’s firmer and provides compression support while serving as a durable base.

Bottom Layer – 6-inch thick high-density polyfoam. Not only is this the layer that keeps it all together, it also helps the mattress become breathable. It’s basically convoluted foam (the ones with the jagged houndstooth look to it.) The little channels in the foam allow air to circulate while the durability prevents the mattress from falling flat or bottoming out.

All in the Cover:

To compete with the rest of the current online mattress companies, Brooklyn Bedding has added a more modern cover to their mattress. It’s a top white cover with beautiful texture. Grey side panels are added and the logo of the company runs along the middle portion as well. Although I love about the quilted top cover, I think too much logo going on. It’s fitted with a 3.4-inch thick polyfoam which acts sort of like a pillow when you sleep. I really love the feeling it offers and it looks chic and modern (without the logos).

What You Will Love About the Brooklyn Bedding Mattress:

Amazing Quality – I think the fact that the company has their own factory has a lot to do with this. Every nook and cranny oozes quality. Even when you check out the foam on the inside, it’s just beautiful.

Firmness Options – Very few online mattress companies give you firmness options, so it’s always nice to see a company who does. Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are available in three firmness levels. I opted for the medium firmness since I know I’m not exactly someone who loves super soft mattresses. (That drowning feeling is just not fun for me.)

All-American Construction – Yes, every single part of this mattress is crafted in the United States of America. So anyone who adores anything American-made will be happy with that fact alone.

The Perfect Bounce – Thanks to its 100%-latex construction, you get a more pronounced bounce with this mattress compared to say a Leesa or even a Yogabed (which I think has a good bounce already.) I’m not going to lie, the entire time I had this mattress in my room, I would sometimes just keep standing up and lying down (with a mild plop) to feel the bounce. It’s seriously the best one I’ve felt.

No Motion Transfer – Despite the softness, you really don’t get much motion transfer with this bed. That’s a total plus if you have someone sharing the bed with you. (Your cat or dog doesn’t count.)

Great Price – March into a physical shop and you’ll be quoted upwards of $2,000 for the same quality of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress. For a mattress that starts at $450 for a Twin and ends at $1,050 for a Split California King, you get a great piece for a mattress your body will thank you for.

Super Long Trial Period – All the basics are covered by the company. You get free shipping within the United States, full 100% refunds and a 10-year warranty to boot! However, the best part is the trial period is the longest one I’ve seen any company offer. Brooklyn Bedding actually gives you 120 days to try out the bed. Pretty neat, and definitely something to be happy with.

Areas for Improvement:

The design – The exterior ticking design bothers me a bit. There’s just… a lot… going on. And the branding seems a bit in your face. This may seem like a small, dumb thing to care about, but I can’t help it. Every detail matters.

Final Verdict:

I’ll say it upfront. I do think this is one of the “best mattresses ever.” Is it “the BEST ever”? I’m not sure. But it’s up there. I’m actually surprised how much I like this mattress. It’s got everything I need: There’s the beautiful bounce minus the discomfort of a spring, the wonderful embedded pillow top layer, and the great pushback support for when I decide to toss and turn.

I think the fact the company has been around since 1995 is also a pretty nice advantage. They know what they’re doing and they know what feels great when you sleep. Aside from that, you just can’t beat the price. For the quality, comfort, feel and support you get, this bed is a solid option.

What Others Say:

They do make buying a mattress online super simple and stress-free.

It’s a pretty heavy-duty, well made product. It weighs as much as a spring mattress, not light and foamy like you would think. Definitely a two-man job moving it around. Why do manufacturers never put handles on mattresses, ever?!


A Brooklyn Bedding Mattress User

It comes rolled up jelly-roll style, so you do have a matter of a few seconds to get it flipped before it really starts to take off, but this thing will start to expand just as soon as you break the seal on the plastic, so be ready. All in all, it was AMAZING to watch as it took shape, and we had NO PROBLEM whatsoever getting it situated on top of our bed foundation. It was full-size in about 3 minutes. I had it all made up within the hour, with only the faintest of smell. We slept on it that night, and it was WONDERFUL! My hip pain, which had bothered me even when lying down, was non-existent as I lay on the bed that first night. Now, after almost 2 weeks, it’s completely gone. What we notice most with this bed is that you don’t feel your partner turn over or get up. It’s FABULOUS!!! If you’re thinking of going latex, I can’t imagine how the $3000 beds could be any better than this.

Piper G.

Another Brooklyn Bedding Mattress User

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Smell
  • Bounciness
  • Edge Support
  • Motion Transfer
  • Sleeps Cool
  • Company
  • Price/Value
Comments Rating 5 (1 review)